You set the keep-or-replace thresholds. Breeders select for different reasons, so this course does not require a mite count, brood-score cutoff, sting count, or age at which a queen must be replaced. What it does ask is that you record the decision, and that you think like a mite-resistance breeder.
A queen you keep in a working colony is not automatically a mite-resistance candidate. Some problems are obvious enough, and well enough supported in the sources below, that she is unlikely to perform long enough or well enough even to be evaluated for resistance. Those are short-term replace-or-cull calls. Other traits take a season or more of records. Those are the long-term resistance criteria. Do not invent a cutoff this lesson does not give. You set your own effective thresholds from your observations and your apiary’s trends.
Confirm what you are actually seeing before you decide. Utah State University Extension: look for eggs, brood in all stages, and pattern over more than one visit. One poor frame, a pause in lay after a dearth or after introduction, or a colony in a swarm or supersedure cycle is not, by itself, a complete case for culling. After you install a purchased queen, look for eggs about 10 to 14 days later. A colony raising its own queen after a split may not have eggs until about day 24 to 28 (USU).
Rule out other causes of a poor pattern or a weak colony: mites, brood disease, nutrition, weather, and season (USU; University of Maryland Bee Lab). A spotty or “shotgun” pattern is a reason to investigate, not automatic proof the queen has failed. Lee, Goblirsch, McDermott, Tarpy, and Spivak (2019) found that brood pattern alone was not a reliable test of queen quality, and that queens from poor-pattern colonies improved after they were moved into good-pattern colonies. Holmes et al. (2023) found that brood disease, including chalkbrood, can explain a poor pattern, and they stress examining brood frames and the bottom board for disease before you blame the queen. Cory Stevens notes that highly hygienic VSH colonies show a lot of uncapping and recapping and can still have good brood patterns and stack supers (American Bee Journal interview, Part 2, 2023). Do not treat hygiene holes as a failing queen.
1. Short-term red flags: replace now, or take her out of the candidate column
These are problems that, once confirmed, mean the queen is unlikely to perform long enough or well enough to be considered a mite-resistance candidate. They support replacing her in a working colony, or at least taking her out of the candidate column. Confirm them across the nest and, unless the failure is already obvious (no queen, a physically defective virgin, a colony that has stayed broodless past the waiting window), across more than one visit.
- She is not laying when she should be, or the colony stays queenless or broodless. USU: no eggs after the queen should be laying; the population is getting smaller. James has written that treated or struggling colonies can “still look weak, lose queens, go broodless, fail to recover” (“Treatments Do Not Solve Genetics or Guarantee Survival,” July 5, 2026). Give a newly introduced or newly mated queen the time USU describes before you call this.
- Laying has clearly declined and the colony is not producing the bees it needs, especially winter bees. James has publicly described a previously successful, multi-winter queen whose egg laying “dialed down,” a boost that did not restore her, and a sudden die-off he suspects came from a failure to raise winter bees (The Shocking Truth About Old Queens, video description). That is a performance problem, not a calendar-age rule. University of Guelph Honey Bee Research Centre requeens if a queen is not doing well, or when she is in her third year. That is HBRC’s practice, not a standard this course requires.
- The brood pattern stays poor through the active season, after you have checked the whole nest, compared earlier notes, and considered disease, nutrition, mites, season, and hygienic uncapping. USU lists a pattern that “stays poor during the active season” among the reasons to consider a new queen. University of Maryland and the Bee Informed Partnership offer a 1-to-5 recording scale (1 the most spotty or “shotgun,” 5 a very solid, compact pattern). Use it to record what you see. This course does not set a pass/fail number on that scale. Holmes et al. found honey yield was lower when average solidness was below 85%. That is a research correlation with honey, not a replace rule for this course.
- The colony keeps making replacement queen cells, or cannot hold a queen. USU lists a colony that “keeps making replacement queen cells” among the reasons to consider a new queen. A single supersedure or swarm cycle is not enough by itself.
- The colony fails to build up, or fails to recover, after other stressors have been considered. James selects for colonies that “build up well” and show “consistency under real conditions,” and he writes against endlessly propping up poor performers (“Why I Got Into Raising Resistant Bees”; “Treatments Do Not Solve Genetics or Guarantee Survival”). Cory’s earlier practice, when he spotted a weak colony, was to replace the old queen; he also looked for brood diseases, nutritional deficiencies, and other stressors “to determine who the losers were” (Rural Missouri profile; American Bee Journal interview, Part 2).
- Ongoing mite or brood-disease trouble that leaves the colony failing. USU includes signs of mites or brood disease among the reasons to consider a new queen. Cory looked for brood diseases when deciding “who the losers were,” and he selects for mite and brood-disease resistance from untreated colonies (Stevens Bee Co. homepage; ABJ Part 2). Diagnose first: disease in the box is not automatically proof the queen is the cause (Lee et al. 2019; Holmes et al. 2023). A colony that cannot stay healthy is unlikely to last as a mite-resistance candidate.
- An obviously defective new queen. Cory culls virgins with dead pupae in the cell, underdeveloped wings, or a leg that does not work, so they do not waste a mating nuc or a colony (“Introducing virgin queens”). He also warns that small, poorly reared queens with underdeveloped ovaries cannot lay enough to build a useful population (“What affects queen quality?”). That cull is about rearing quality. It is a different decision from replacing a laying queen later.
- Temperament you will not live with. James’s selection language emphasizes gentle temperament (James Lee’s Bees product pages). Cory will not even assay a colony that is “overly aggressive,” after it has also wintered, been productive, and been vigorous (ABJ Part 2). Neither publishes a sting-count or other numeric fail line. You set this threshold. This course does not require one.
If the colony is already too weak to requeen cleanly, the endgame (requeen, combine, condense, or take the colony down) is your call. James has shown fall combines to rescue a weak hive while protecting a young queen. This lesson does not set a required combine-or-dispose rule.
2. Long-term mite-resistance traits: before you call her a candidate
A queen who is laying, building up, and otherwise functional is still not a mite-resistance candidate until the records support it. Last year’s reputation is not a free pass. As James writes, “Real breeder evaluation is not just opening a box, seeing a nice brood pattern, and feeling good about the colony” (“What Real Breeder Evaluation Looks Like”).
Look at these traits over the season, and more than once. Do not select on a single measure.
- Mite loads and the trend over the season. Colonies that “repeatedly stay under acceptable thresholds” and “keep mite loads low without treatment” are more useful as candidates than colonies that “simply happened to survive” (James, “Using Monitoring Data for Better Bee Selection”). “A single low mite wash is interesting. Repeated low mite washes are useful.” Colonies “starting to creep upward” lose standing compared with those that stay low (“What Real Breeder Evaluation Looks Like”). You set the acceptable threshold and write it down (see the checklist). The mite-wash method already used in this course does not change: about 300 nurse bees, monthly through the active season and fall, with colony ID, date, queen identity or lineage, mite count, infestation %, tester, location, and treatment status. This lesson does not attach a required percent to that protocol.
- Survival without being propped up, including winter. James wants colonies that overwinter, maintain low mite levels, and show consistency, and he wants to know which ones did it without treatment. “Sometimes bees survive because of the beekeeper and not because of the bees.” A treated colony may survive for a while, “but that does not automatically make it stock worth keeping,” and it is not automatically stock worth building a breeding program around (“If You Treat Everybody and Monitor Nobody, You’re Getting Nowhere”; “Treatments Do Not Solve Genetics or Guarantee Survival”). Cory does not test a colony as a breeder until it has “survived a winter, [is] productive, vigorous, and not overly aggressive” (ABJ Part 2).
- Buildup, vigor, and consistency under real conditions. James: overwinter, build up well, and show consistency. Productivity, gentleness, wintering, and “a story behind it” are “not enough by itself” for breeder status; the records have to keep supporting the colony (“Why I Got Into Raising Resistant Bees”; “What Real Breeder Evaluation Looks Like”).
- Hygienic behavior, and later resistance testing. James wants to know what the brood looks like, whether the colony has brood of the right age for a pin-killed brood test, and whether a Harbo confirmation frame can be pulled, along with whether it is still queenright and has enough resources (“What Real Breeder Evaluation Looks Like”). Formal pin-killed brood (PKB) and Simplified Harbo / VSH assays are later evaluations for selected breeder candidates (Level 2). They are not a Level 1 requirement, and this lesson does not change those field-protocol thresholds. Cory selects for mite and brood-disease resistance from untreated colonies and uses Harbo’s VSH assay on overwintered colonies; for breeder and drone stock he only keeps “the high scorers around.” A lower resistance score is not, in his account, an automatic production cull — some low-scoring colonies still make honey or survive — but it keeps them out of the breeder and drone pool (Stevens Bee Co. homepage; ABJ Part 2). He and his helpers also look for colonies with few mites, or with mites that have been attacked by the bees (Rural Missouri).
Breeder advancement, when it comes later, combines mite-wash history, spring and fall PKB, Harbo, overwinter survival, treatment history, lineage, and production. Never select on one measure. That combined decision is later work, not a Level 1 keep-or-replace number.
3. Keep / replace / watch checklist
For each colony, record the date, colony ID, and queen identity or lineage, then mark Watch, Replace, or Keep. Fill in your own lines where a blank is given. Compare this visit with earlier notes.
Watch — you do not have a complete case yet:
- The problem is on only one frame or one visit
- Lay may be paused after introduction, a dearth, or a swarm or supersedure cycle
- You have not yet ruled out mites, brood disease, nutrition, weather, or season
- A new queen has not yet had the time USU describes (about 10 to 14 days after a purchased queen is installed; about 24 to 28 days if the colony is raising its own)
Replace, or take her out of the mite-resistance candidate column, when the short-term red flags above are confirmed:
- Not laying when she should be; queenless, broodless, or shrinking
- Laying has declined and the colony is not producing the bees it needs
- Brood pattern has stayed poor through the active season after other causes were considered
- The colony keeps making replacement queen cells, or cannot hold a queen
- Failure to build up, or failure to recover
- Ongoing mite or brood-disease trouble, and the colony is failing
- A new queen is physically defective (dead pupa, bad wings or legs, clearly underdeveloped)
- Temperament is past the line you have set: ________________
Keep as a working queen if she is laying and the colony is functional. That is not the same thing as calling her a mite-resistance candidate. Before you make that second call, look at the longer record:
- Repeated mite washes through the season: the load and the trend. Set your own effective mite threshold based on your observations and your apiary’s trends, and write it down: __________. Colonies that start to climb lose standing compared with those that stay low.
- Did she keep mites low without being propped up? Treatment history: __________
- Did the colony overwinter and build up well? Winter and buildup notes: __________
- Is performance consistent under real conditions, visit after visit?
- Hygienic behavior and later VSH / PKB / Harbo testing belong to later evaluation of selected candidates. They are not a Level 1 requirement. Notes if you already have them: __________
If you do replace the queen, first remove the old queen. Guelph’s requeening protocol is clear: there is no point introducing a new queen unless the old queen has been removed, because the colony will not accept the new one. Also find and remove leftover queen cells. Guelph has its best success when the colony has been queenless for 24 hours before the new queen goes in, and it introduces the new queen in a candy-release cage, next to a solid frame of capped brood, screen side toward the bees, on a slight tilt with the candy side down, and wedged so it cannot fall. Then leave the colony alone for a week before checking for eggs. Opening too soon can get her killed.
After a week, look for eggs. You do not have to find the new queen if eggs are present. If there are no eggs, look for the queen; if she is gone, you may need to try again (Guelph).
Record the decision, the date, colony ID, and queen identity or lineage.
Sources: University of Guelph Honey Bee Research Centre, Requeening, the Re-Queening protocol page, and the Queens FAQ; Utah State University Extension, How Can I Tell if My Queen Is Healthy?; University of Maryland Bee Lab, Rating Brood Pattern; Bee Informed Partnership / Illinois brood-pattern info sheet; Kathleen V. Lee, Michael Goblirsch, Erin McDermott, David R. Tarpy, and Marla Spivak, “Is the Brood Pattern within a Honey Bee Colony a Reliable Indicator of Queen Quality?” Insects 10(1): 12 (2019); L.A. Holmes et al., “Queen quality, performance, and winter survival of imported and domestic honey bee queen stocks,” Scientific Reports (2023); James Lee’s Bees posts cited above; James Lee and Matthew Kobe, “The Path of Most Resistance: An interview with queen breeder Cory Stevens, Part 2,” American Bee Journal 163(11), November 2023; Stevens Bee Co. homepage and posts “What affects queen quality?” and “Introducing virgin queens”; Jim McCarty, “From Stings to Success,” Rural Missouri.
Use the video for the removal-and-introduction method, not as a substitute for the keep-or-replace judgment in this lesson. HBRC’s own practice note (they requeen if a queen is not doing well, or when she is in her third year) is their practice, not a standard this course requires.
Optional link (cleared): Early Queen Supersedure, Bob Binnie, 7:49
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYu7QHVc6vY
Optional link (cleared): The Shocking Truth About Old Queens: It’s a Matter of Life and Death!, James Lees Bees, 8:29
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJ_N-MIz3C4
The posted description is the source used in this lesson (egg laying “dialed down,” a boost, then a suspected winter-bee failure). A spoken transcript was not obtained. Use the video as optional context, not as a numeric rule.
Files / PDFs: Guelph’s Requeening-Protocol PDF is linked from the HBRC requeening page if you want the written protocol next to the video.
Article links:
https://extension.usu.edu/answers/articles/how-can-i-tell-if-my-queen-is-healthy
https://www.umdbeelab.com/broodpattern.html
https://jamesleesbees.com/what-real-breeder-evaluation-looks-like